Tesla Model Y or Ford Mustang Mach-E: Which EV Packs the Bigger Punch?

When choosing an electric SUV, many drivers compare the Ford Mustang Mach-E to the Tesla Model Y.Both models offer a powerful performance, stability, range and advanced technology, but have their own unique advantages, may affect the choice of potential buyers. Model Y highlights its industry-leading range and charging convenience as selling points, while Mach-E stands out with its unique exterior design and comfortable riding experience.Choose which car is best for yourself, depending on the price, driving experience, cargo space and multiple factors such as brand preference.

2025 Tesla Model Y Versions

The lineup of Tesla's Model Y in 2025 is mainly based on the Long Range AWD, specifically designed for drivers seeking long range and high efficiency.That version comes with all-wheel drive and dual electric motors, offering a range of about 327 miles. The acceleration performance is approximately 4.6 seconds from 0 to 60 miles per hour, providing larger cargo hold space and standard heated seats. All versions come standard with a panoramic glass roof, autopilot and minimalist interior, and support wireless software updates.In addition, customers can choose from different exterior colors, interiors and wheel designs, ensuring that diverse needs are met.

2025 Ford Mustang Mach-E Versions

The 2025 Ford Mustang Mach-E is available in four main versions: Select, Premium, GT and Rally. Both the Select and Premium versions offer RWD and eAWD options. The EPA estimated range of the Select version is 260 miles (RWD) or 300 miles (Extended-range battery eAWD). The Premium version offers 260 miles (range-extended battery RWD). The GT version focuses on sports performance, equipped with eAWD, providing strong power and fast acceleration. The Rally version is specially designed for off-roading and adventure, featuring special decorations and capabilities.

Each version includes the SYNC 4A system, supports wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, and offers multiple color options, such as Molten magenta metal, Speed Blue Metal and Star White metal.In terms of exterior design, the Mach-E displays bold coupe style and muscular lines, while the Tesla Y boasts a clean, sleek surface and minimalist silhouette.

Dimensions Comparison

In terms of size, the Ford Mustang Mach-E is very similar to the Tesla Model Y, but the Model Y is longer and wider.Specifically, the Mach - E 186 inches long and 74 inches wide, 64 inches high, and the Model Y 187 inches long and 75.6 inches wide, 63.9 inches tall. Although the two are spatially close, the Y-type slightly increases the width and length, enabling it to provide more interior space. In terms of interior design, the Mach-E integrates physical buttons and digital displays while maintaining a modern feel. Among them, the 15.5-inch touchscreen and the display screen behind the steering wheel stand out particularly.The Model Y, by contrast, has fully digital controls, with only a 15-inch horizontal touch screen controlling all functions and few physical buttons.Both cars offer a panoramic glass roof to bring a sense of openness to the owner, and the Mach-E also features a rotary gear shift lever and synthetic leather seats to emphasize driving comfort and luxury. Model Y focuses on the minimalist style, offers a minimalist dashboard design, and can be optionally equipped with the third-row seats, accommodating up to 7 people.For home use, the rear and cargo space of both Mach-E and Model Y are fairly spacious, making them suitable for long trips and daily trips.

Performance Comparison

In terms of performance, both the Ford Mustang Mach-E and the Tesla Model Y offer efficient electric powertrains with different trim and configurations. The acceleration of the Mach-E GT is only 3.8 seconds from 0 to 60 miles per hour, and the Model Y Performance can also complete the acceleration within 4.6 seconds. Both vehicles are equipped with all-wheel drive, providing excellent traction and handling. Although the peak horsepower of the Mach-E GT is 480 horsepower, which is higher than that of the Model Y Performance, the two are almost comparable in acceleration. In terms of range, the EPA estimate of the Model Y Performance is 327 miles, and that of the Mach-E GT is 280 miles. Both models are equipped with advanced driver assistance functions. Model Y has Tesla's autopilot system, while Mach-E offers Ford's Blue Cruise system. In terms of handling, the Mach-E tends to have a more sporty heavy steering feeling, while the Model Y focuses on light steering and emphasizes efficiency and comfort.

Technology and Systems Comparison

Both the Ford Mustang Mach-E and the Tesla Model Y feature advanced technology, but they differ in their user experience. Tesla's in-vehicle infotainment system features a simple 15-inch central touchscreen, integrates various applications and offers powerful wireless software update capabilities. This system focuses on simplifying the operation interface and has almost no physical buttons.

The Mach-E, by contrast, features a 15.5-inch vertical touch screen with physical volume controls and a SYNC 4A system that emphasizes voice commands and smartphone connectivity.Both vehicles support wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, but Ford offers more direct integration services that enhance the smart, connected experience.

Driver Assistance Suite Comparison

Both the Ford Mach-E (360 Co-pilot) and the Tesla Model Y (autonomous driving) are equipped with advanced driving assistance functions, including adaptive cruise control and lane keeping assist.The Mach-E also offers automatic parking with an optional upgrade, while the Model Y comes with autopilot and an optional Fully autonomous driving (FSD) package.

Both vehicles feature keyless entry, wireless charging, and a smartphone as a key.Ford's system stands out for physical control of climate and audio, while Tesla maintains an entirely digital interface. The connection options include the Wi-Fi hotspot of Mach-E and the built-in streaming media and Internet browsing of Model Y. Both of these two vehicles have cloud-connected navigation systems that can update the map in real time. Model Y also integrates Tesla's supercharging station network to achieve seamless route planning.Drivers in Mach-E rely on Ford's integrated partner network, accessible through the FordPass app.

Range and Charging Comparison

Ford mustang Mach - E offers a variety of options in life and charging ways, to meet different requirements of driving. Its range varies depending on different configurations and can reach up to 320 miles at the longest. With level 1 charging, the range can be increased by approximately 3 miles per hour, making it suitable for emergency situations or overnight charging. Level 2 charging offers a more efficient charging speed, supporting up to 11 kilowatts of AC charging. It can charge the battery from 10% to 80% within 8.5 hours. The Mustang Mach-E is also equipped with a mobile application, which is convenient for users to monitor and arrange home charging time.

The Tesla Model Y performs exceptionally well in terms of range and charging capacity, with a maximum range of up to 327 miles. When using level 1 charging, the range can be increased by 3 to 5 miles per hour, making it suitable for emergency or overnight charging. The level 2 charging  provides a maximum charging power of 11.5 kilowatts. The charging time is relatively short, and it takes about 7 to 8 hours to charge the battery from 10% to 80%.Tesla's charging system is also very convenient, providing a powerful mobile app to manage charging and charging schedules, ensuring drivers experience an efficient charging process.

DC fast charging is crucial for long-distance travel and public charging. The Mustang Mach-E supports a peak charging rate of up to 150 kilowatts, while the Tesla Model Y can receive a charging power of up to 250 kilowatts at supercharging stations. It takes approximately 38 minutes for the Mach-E to charge to 80%, while the Model Y long range takes 25 minutes. Tesla's supercharger station network is renowned for its high reliability and charging speed, while Mach-E uses the network of the U.S. Company. Although the coverage is increasing, it may not be as stable as Tesla's system. Both models offer charging station navigation, and Tesla's system is usually more accurate.

Conclusion

The Ford Mustang Mach-E and the Tesla Model Y each have advantages in terms of cost, performance, functionality and driving range. Consumers should choose the most suitable vehicle model based on their own budget and needs. By the beginning of 2025, the basic Model of Mach-E will be priced approximately starting form $36,495, while the basic version of Model Y will be priced starting form $41,490. Both models are eligible for federal tax benefits and state tax refunds, but the specific eligibility depends on factors such as the source of the battery and the buyer's income. Tesla's base price includes Autopilot, while Ford's BlueCruise is standard on some models.

When choosing a suitable model, buyers should consider daily driving range, technology preference and budget.The range of the Mustang Mach-E ranges from 250 to 320 miles, and models with extended range options raise total costs. The cruising range of the Tesla Model Y Long Range 327 miles. Tesla has a broader charging network, which is particularly important for long-distance drivers. Meanwhile, Ford is expanding its third-party charging network, but it has not yet reached the scale of Tesla.In terms of technology and software preferences, the Model Y's system may be more appealing to those seeking innovation, while the Mach-E focuses on comfort and traditional driving controls.